If I ask you; "Who do think was the driver of the race?", and you reply:
"Max Chilton." Should I then say; "Oh! No you don't, you think Grosjean was."
I am arguing with you about your choice! Very stupid of course.
I can disagree, and say; " I thought that Pic was far more impressive.", and this is part of normal discourse between friends, which we all are of course ..... aren't we?