Montoya's defending style

Jukebox · 19 Aug 2002, 06:04 (Ref:360892)

He does it again and this time nearly knocking into Kimi's car by trying to defend his line although he dosen't have the pace and with a slightly damaged car after carelessly driving through a chicane.

I know this would look like a flame bait thread but am i the only one to see that the guy only thinks for himself and only sees that nobody can get the better of him?

Arrogant is the right word.

**Peter Mallett** · 19 Aug 2002, 06:36 (Ref:360903)

I was thinking about this last night. He's definitely good when he's chasing a postion but his methods of defence are not so much arrogant as amateur. Whilst it doesn't happen every time, he does, quite often, seem to defend too hard for his car's capabilities.

z2252314 · 19 Aug 2002, 07:16 (Ref:360921)

Agree with Mallet. Montoya seems confortable chasing and outbreaking someone off a straight, but when hes under pressure he has a tendency to crack.

Mania · 19 Aug 2002, 07:32 (Ref:360932)

It was a pretty amateur move by Montoya. First, he qualified a second behind his team mate, next he made a poor start and got swamped by everyone. Then he made 2 major mistakes under preassure,, running wide and kicking up the dust which let Kimi get closer - he repeated the error next time around and Kimi did the smart thing - he didnt try diving all over the place - he correctly figured that Montoya would go off line to defend and as a result he ran wide yet again, this time damaging his car.

I think Kimi was quite pleased having suckered Montoya into that one.

It certainly hasnt been a good 4-5 weeks for Pablo. Maybe he's realizing that this time around he has to work for his points and not have them handed to him through his team mate's mis-fortune.

Full Boost · 19 Aug 2002, 09:36 (Ref:361011)

Poor start! Do u people know anything about F1!! Every racer on the dirty side of the track had a bad start...Why single Montoya out???

**Dani Filth** · 19 Aug 2002, 09:58 (Ref:361030)

he .. MS didn't .... why is that

Jukebox · 19 Aug 2002, 10:02 (Ref:361032)

Quote:

Originally posted by Dani Filth
he .. MS didn't .... why is that

There's always a difference between a brilliant and an over-zealous

**Dani Filth** · 19 Aug 2002, 10:07 (Ref:361038)

Yep.... you've got it

Dino IV · 19 Aug 2002, 10:21 (Ref:361050)

What was wrong with the way JPM tried to fend off Kimi?? Nothing but clean moves. weren't they? They left eachother room. It was more Kimi bouncing off the inside curb (although he did so nicely in control) which forced JPM to go even more wide, running out of track.

BootsOntheSide · 19 Aug 2002, 10:32 (Ref:361061)

Michael's start wasn't great, if it had been Montoya third on the grid the place would've changed, but it was Monty's fault that he was so far off Ralf's pace in qualifying. I don't think it can be singled out as a poor start- Irvine was the only one to gain palces form the dirty side of the grid.

ttc · 19 Aug 2002, 11:41 (Ref:361124)

I've have to concur. MS's start was not a good one, but rarely have we seen perfect starts for MS. That's one area where he most definitely needs to improve...

But back on thread, Montoya's defensive moves leaves a lot to be desired. He tends to be easily pressurized into mistakes. (BTW, that DOES NOT automatically imply that MS is better in any way

)

Mania · 19 Aug 2002, 11:46 (Ref:361129)

Quote:

Originally posted by ttc
Montoya's defensive moves leaves a lot to be desired. He tends to be easily pressurized into mistakes. (BTW, that DOES NOT automatically imply that MS is better in any way )

I dont think Michael can be preassurized into mistakes - in fact, he usually goes off when he's on his own and the team keeps telling him to go slower and slower. His spin in Indy in 2000 was mainly because of him falling asleep behind the wheel !

**Peter Mallett** · 19 Aug 2002, 12:10 (Ref:361148)

Quote:

Originally posted by Dino IV
What was wrong with the way JPM tried to fend off Kimi?? Nothing but clean moves. weren't they? They left eachother room. It was more Kimi bouncing off the inside curb (although he did so nicely in control) which forced JPM to go even more wide, running out of track.

Nothing wrong as far as I could see. I think the only problem was that he seems unable to take the pressure.

So far not the mark of a champion by any means.

BTW. It's worth noting here that Raikonnen went off in Hockenheim whilst JPM was attempting to pass, but in his case it wasn't so damaging. Nor was it as far of the road.

As with other attempts at defending JPM is definitely over zealous to his own detriment.

Legend · 19 Aug 2002, 12:40 (Ref:361178)

Quote:

Originally posted by z2252314
Agree with Mallet. Montoya seems confortable chasing and outbreaking someone off a straight, but when hes under pressure he has a tendency to crack.

Exactly my words no need to reply my thoughts here, this could be my reply!

Amen mate

Jay · 19 Aug 2002, 13:05 (Ref:361209)

"People say that he has big balls, but maybe it's a case of big balls and a small brain." - David Coulthard.

This is true, but isn't that why he is great to watch?

Inigo Montoya · 19 Aug 2002, 13:12 (Ref:361216)

Arrogant? Definitely. Aggressive? Yup. Questionable tactics? Certainly.

Remind you of anyone? I thought so. This is why when people say he's the next TGF, I believe them.

**Bononi** · 19 Aug 2002, 13:15 (Ref:361218)

Ouch... David Coulthard, look in the mirror.

JPM proved this weekend that he doesn't like this kind of circuit... he was nowhere on that track. Not a good thing for a wannabe champion.

neilap · 19 Aug 2002, 13:28 (Ref:361228)

http://f1.racing-live.com/en/index.html?http://f1.racing-live.com/en/headlin...19050129.shtml
It seems that people expect JPM to roll over and play dead. Again, this is racing. Is Kimmi complaining about the moves made by JPM? No! Instead it is a man on the decline that has once again been proven to be the slower of the Mac drivers. I am willing to bet that if JPM was in the situation that RS was he would have passed MS. MS, himself admitted he had a bad start, in fact he said it was like driving on ice. RS did not take advantage of it. Also, would MS have rolled over and played dead if anyone was passing him? Is he not the one that has taken out at least 2 drivers in his bid for world titles? Is he not the one that has even run his brother off line to help his own team and team mate? Sorry I disagree with most of the sentiments here. Kimmi did and awesome job and JPM did what he could with a car that was damaged by a Renault.

From his first year JPM has said he is not in racing to move out of the way he is here to race that is what he does and does really well. This track definitely suited RS more than him and he was outclassed by his teammate this weekend but so was MS!

All of the drivers on the grid are wanna be champions except MS and JV!

freud · 19 Aug 2002, 13:42 (Ref:361240)

Even a maniac would understand that JPM's car was undrivable, his set-up sucked & him dont liking the track didnt help him much. He was trying hard to defend hs position, made a mistake and himself suffered damage.. didnt hurt anyone, didnt push anyone off the track deliberately. This is a meaningless thread!!

Legend · 19 Aug 2002, 13:46 (Ref:361246)

Quote:

Originally posted by David Coulthard lol

"People say that he (Monty) has big balls, but maybe it's a case of big balls and a small brain."

Follow the rest of the story here. DC go for him!!!

freud · 19 Aug 2002, 13:48 (Ref:361250)

Legend, I see that DC making a jibe at JPM has made you very happy. Enjoy the fun while it lasts..

Jay · 19 Aug 2002, 13:48 (Ref:361251)

I thought he was pretty fair on that move actually, he didn't turn into Kimi, but he made it difficult for him. His only mistake was not lifting a bit more to keep his own car on the track.

Legend · 19 Aug 2002, 13:55 (Ref:361254)

Quote:

Originally posted by freud
Legend, I see that DC making a jibe at JPM has made you very happy. Enjoy the fun while it lasts..

Freud sometimes I feel like I am the only one.

It is nice to feel that I am not alone, well I have company here from the Highlander him self, and well F1 Rambo is the target. Should I get angry at DC? No way!

**Peter Mallett** · 19 Aug 2002, 14:04 (Ref:361264)

I didn't think this was an attack on JPM's style because of any wrongdoing. I thought we were commenting on his menatl ability to cope with pressure. Which is currently found to be wanting.

freud · 19 Aug 2002, 14:14 (Ref:361270)

When Kimi Raikonnen went off a few laps before the chequered flag at Magny Cours, some idiots thought that he 'couldnt cope with the pressure'.. And now the same thing with JPM.

JPM is a title winner and a proven 'one of the best ever' at CART, which is the fastest and most dangerous motorsport series in world. He doesnt need to prove to any %#$%^# that he cannot cope with pressure.

If I was to give an explanation of JPM's mistake I would say that he was too ambitious. I can see that from someone as talented and confident as JPM who is in F1 to win titles and not fool around. If I were Patrick Head I would advise him to calm down in situations like these and just let the faster car overtake him (Just like Ralf always does). Thing is that Patrick Head pushes him even harder and thinks that at this stage of the season JPM has nothing to lose and should go for it.

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Defending IDE	Phoenix1	Formula One	240	18 May 2009 17:03
Blocking Vs. Defending	gttouring	ChampCar World Series	10	18 Apr 2003 23:29
Montoya's driving style	Sodemo	Formula One	13	15 Jun 2001 21:59
Montoya, Will he race as a defending champion?	kuchi	ChampCar World Series	4	17 Aug 2000 22:07