|
||||||||||
|
||||||||||
21 Jul 2009, 10:52 (Ref:2505363) | #76 | ||
CCNA
Royalridge Computing A LARGE Teapot Veteran
Join Date: Oct 2001
Posts: 10,691
|
Quote:
Motorsport is dangerous. Everything that can be done is done to make it as safe as possible, but the simple fact of the matter is, sometimes things go wrong. Drivers choose which series they race in. They know their cars and they know the risks. They always have the choice to move to a different racing class or simply walk away from the sport if they feel that it's not safe enough. The only way to ensure you don't get hurt in motorsport is not to be there. When something as terrible as this happens, the first impulse is always to find someone to blame, but there's nothing to indicate that there was any blatent negligence here. The drivers all knew their cars, knew what safety features were on those cars and chose to race in them with that full knowledge. They weren't lied to, no-one forced them into the car. Ultimately, it is always and only their decision whether or not it is safe for them to race. It's a hard truth to deal with, particularly with events as tragic as this, but it doesn't change anything. |
||
__________________
If you feel that the circuit is not safe for racing, please go into the pits and retire. |
21 Jul 2009, 11:13 (Ref:2505368) | #77 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Sep 2006
Posts: 12,853
|
Quite right too! Henry came from a rather famous family where Racing is "in the blood",he of all people would have been very aware of the risk involved.It could have been anyone at any event throughout the world for any given reason.It was unfortunately,one of those distastfull things that happen occasionally throughout our live's.There is no 100% way of stopping wheel's coming off,all that can be done is minimise that risk.
|
||
__________________
Living the dream,Chief instruktor and racing on the worlds best circuits-The Nordschleife and Spa.Getting to drive the worlds best cars-someone has to do it, so glad its me. |
21 Jul 2009, 11:18 (Ref:2505369) | #78 | |
CCNA
Royalridge Computing A LARGE Teapot Veteran
Join Date: Oct 2001
Posts: 10,691
|
That's not to say that I don't think an examination of the safety features of the cars should now be done with a view to making them safer. Obviously the tethers they have are not working as well as they should and, while I don't think there was any intent to skimp on safety, now that this issue has been so tragically brought to light, it needs to be addressed. That doesn't mean that anyone (or any organisation) did anything wrong - but now that we know about this problem, it can't be ignored going forward.
|
|
__________________
If you feel that the circuit is not safe for racing, please go into the pits and retire. |
21 Jul 2009, 11:43 (Ref:2505383) | #79 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2006
Posts: 5,493
|
Quote:
|
||
|
21 Jul 2009, 11:50 (Ref:2505388) | #80 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Nov 2004
Posts: 2,156
|
Of course there are questions being raised and rightly so. But I can't help thinking that isn't it a known fact that in single-seaters the driver's head is still exposed somewhat? Of course there are now high cockpit sides, but the front of the head is still vulnerable. I read this accident as a freak one, where unfortunately the wheel of Clarke's car just happened to bounce and hit the most vulnerable part of Henry's helmet straight on. Blame doesn't come into this, but obviously wheel tethers seem like an issue in this case.
|
||
__________________
Steve McQueen- "Racing is life. Anything before or after is just waiting." |
21 Jul 2009, 11:59 (Ref:2505391) | #81 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2006
Posts: 5,493
|
Quote:
|
||
|
21 Jul 2009, 12:14 (Ref:2505405) | #82 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Sep 2006
Posts: 12,853
|
Tether or not there is still no getting away from the fact that a wheel can 'escape'.The tether can only be affixed to a non revolving component such as the Upright,then that comes into the question of "Is it strong enough",did the securing bolt shear? etc etc. The questions will just keep coming and coming,another point being,would the wheel have been launched in the same manor if it had not been tethered? Ad infinitum!
|
||
__________________
Living the dream,Chief instruktor and racing on the worlds best circuits-The Nordschleife and Spa.Getting to drive the worlds best cars-someone has to do it, so glad its me. |
21 Jul 2009, 12:18 (Ref:2505408) | #83 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2006
Posts: 4,742
|
The problem with tethers are that if you make them too strong, they can pull the cars apart which could make it even more dangerous
Also a lot of it has to do with the angle of impact and the type of barrier. Kubica in Australia and Clarke at Brands hit tyre walls at similar angles, whereas in the IRL, where they also use tethers, you don't see many wheels off despite the higher speeds It's worth thinking about but sometimes things like this are unavoidable |
||
|
21 Jul 2009, 12:34 (Ref:2505418) | #84 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Nov 2002
Posts: 2,073
|
You can not help noticing though that seemingly those two incidents were rather different in their violencity. That's why some (including myself) have the impression that tethers need to be looked at for this car.
|
||
|
21 Jul 2009, 12:40 (Ref:2505421) | #85 | ||
Race Official
Veteran
Join Date: Jun 2001
Posts: 13,038
|
May I suggest that we all read Jonathan Palmers statement on the MSV website
www.motorsportvision.co.uk |
||
__________________
The Priest Catcher Honoured recipient of the BARC Browning Medal |
21 Jul 2009, 12:49 (Ref:2505426) | #86 | ||||
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2006
Posts: 4,742
|
Quote:
Quote:
I honestly don't believe there is a problem. Tethers have always been unreliable and always will be because you can never fully account for all eventualities in crash tests and the like. The areas I'm most concerned about are side impacts, T-bones and the like, but again difficult to solve |
||||
|
21 Jul 2009, 12:50 (Ref:2505427) | #87 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Sep 2006
Posts: 12,853
|
I would also suggest,after reading that,that in respect of Henry,this thread be closed,there is nothing anyone on here can do about this tragedy.
|
||
__________________
Living the dream,Chief instruktor and racing on the worlds best circuits-The Nordschleife and Spa.Getting to drive the worlds best cars-someone has to do it, so glad its me. |
21 Jul 2009, 13:34 (Ref:2505463) | #88 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 1,208
|
|||
|
21 Jul 2009, 14:42 (Ref:2505495) | #89 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Apr 2005
Posts: 5,652
|
Sorry, I don't want to take anything away from the sad story that has started this discussion with what may appear to be a flippant comment, but one thing that worries me is that, if the wheel tethers are strengthened it could lead to additional (and heavier) components being ripped off with the wheel in a high speed accident.
|
||
__________________
Incognito: An Italian phrase meaning Nice Gearchange! |
21 Jul 2009, 15:05 (Ref:2505509) | #90 | |
Veteran
Join Date: Feb 2005
Posts: 6,986
|
On a more philosophical level, it would appear that this was a freak accident - a case of being in the wrong place at the wrong time. Incredibly sad though it may be, any of us could fall victim to being in the wrong place at the wrong time. Only by the grace of God/luck/whatever you want to call it, is it not us. Think of a fallen tree landing on a passing car on the road, victims on the ground of the Lockerbie disaster, tsunami victims from a few years ago.
More information may emerge when the authorities investigate fully, but we ought to be prepared for them to pronouce it nothing more than a highly improbable freak accident. In an attempt to footnote this discussion and show our own respect to Henry and the Surtees family, maybe its best that we remain silent until the full facts are known, investigated and published rather than debating/surmising on the basis of partial information and/or hearsay. |
|
|
21 Jul 2009, 15:08 (Ref:2505511) | #91 | |||
Race Official
Veteran
Join Date: May 2003
Posts: 11,142
|
Quote:
|
|||
|
21 Jul 2009, 15:39 (Ref:2505522) | #92 | ||
Race Official
Veteran
Join Date: Aug 2001
Posts: 4,010
|
Isnt a Turnip a Swede? Anyway Im surprised this hasnt been pulled by Crash yet as they have, perhaps understandably, pulled a few others:
http://www.crash.net/f3/comments/150...or_racing.html |
||
__________________
Andretti, Mario: Auto racing legend owns the rights to an unspecified Spinal Tap song, which he purchased when former manager Ian Faith secretly sold the band’s catalog |
21 Jul 2009, 15:44 (Ref:2505524) | #93 | ||
Subscriber
Veteran
Join Date: Apr 2007
Posts: 12,350
|
As commented, the exposure of the head in a single-seater is a potential for risk.
The head can be struck by any item of debris, be it bodywork, wheels, or possibly even wildlife. Should the exposure of the head be looked at possibly and consideration made for something akin to a fighter aircraft cockpit canopy? |
||
__________________
"When you’re just too socially awkward for real life, Ten-Tenths welcomes you with open arms. Everyone has me figured out, which makes it super easy for me." |
21 Jul 2009, 17:51 (Ref:2505615) | #94 | |
Race Official
Veteran
Join Date: Dec 1998
Posts: 16,760
|
thread closed pending a discussion amongst the moderators. in the meantime please respect the condolences thread and keep speculation to yourselves.
many thanks. |
|
__________________
devils advocate in-chief and professional arguer of both sides |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
TWPC 2009 F2 Predictions - R04 Brands Hatch | Mekola | National & International Single Seaters | 11 | 17 Jul 2009 13:35 |
DMN Brands Hatch Weekend/Brands 12th Aug merged | chezza | National & Club Racing | 114 | 24 Aug 2007 15:47 |
Brands Hatch | pitpopsie | Marshals Forum | 15 | 17 Mar 2002 22:31 |
Brands Hatch | Dan Friel | Formula One | 9 | 12 Sep 2000 16:12 |
BRANDS HATCH | davy | Trackside | 48 | 30 Aug 2000 18:43 |