Home  
Site Partners: SpotterGuides Veloce Books  
Related Sites: FlagMarshal.com MarshalsGuide.com Your Link Here  

Go Back   TenTenths Motorsport Forum > Racing Talk > Marshals Forum

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 7 Oct 2002, 09:40 (Ref:397365)   #1
Stephen Green
Race Official
Veteran
 
Stephen Green's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
England
Faversham, Kent
Posts: 13,038
Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!
Roll Cages

For some time I have been pointing out to scrutineers the fact that some drivers helmets are level or above the roll hoop/cage when racing. It seems the problem stems from the fact they are not scrutineered whilst sat in the car wearing their crash helmets.

It has got to the stage now where I have started to submit written reports to the Clerk of the Course in a vein attampt that something might be done about this before one of us has to go and scrape some poor persons head from the track.

Has anyone else noticed this or am I being 'picky'?

The question then is 'what do we do to stop this alarming practice?'
Stephen Green is offline  
__________________
The Priest Catcher
Honoured recipient of the BARC Browning Medal
Quote
Old 7 Oct 2002, 11:57 (Ref:397458)   #2
Dave Brand
Veteran
 
Dave Brand's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2001
England
Hadfield, Derbyshire (UK)
Posts: 6,358
Dave Brand is going for a new lap record!Dave Brand is going for a new lap record!Dave Brand is going for a new lap record!Dave Brand is going for a new lap record!Dave Brand is going for a new lap record!Dave Brand is going for a new lap record!
Re: Roll Cages

Quote:
Originally posted by Stephen Green
Has anyone else noticed this or am I being 'picky'?
I've noticed it, & commented on it; maybe I'm 'picky' too.....
Dave Brand is offline  
Quote
Old 7 Oct 2002, 12:06 (Ref:397461)   #3
Stephen Green
Race Official
Veteran
 
Stephen Green's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
England
Faversham, Kent
Posts: 13,038
Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!
It came to a head on Saturday when some of the Caterham drivers had helmets dangerously close to the top of the roll cage, or they had to drive with their head to one side to stop it hitting the cross member above their head.

I guess we will have to wait until we are asked to remove someones brains from the tarmac before anything gets done.

One has to wonder at the effectiveness of the MSA in these circumstances?
Stephen Green is offline  
__________________
The Priest Catcher
Honoured recipient of the BARC Browning Medal
Quote
Old 7 Oct 2002, 12:17 (Ref:397470)   #4
EvilPumpkin
CCNA
Royalridge Computing
A LARGE Teapot
Veteran
 
Join Date: Oct 2001
Ireland
Posts: 10,691
EvilPumpkin is going for a new world record!EvilPumpkin is going for a new world record!EvilPumpkin is going for a new world record!EvilPumpkin is going for a new world record!EvilPumpkin is going for a new world record!EvilPumpkin is going for a new world record!EvilPumpkin is going for a new world record!EvilPumpkin is going for a new world record!
What's actually in the regulations regarding this?
EvilPumpkin is offline  
__________________
If you feel that the circuit is not safe for racing, please go into the pits and retire.
Quote
Old 7 Oct 2002, 12:22 (Ref:397473)   #5
Stephen Green
Race Official
Veteran
 
Stephen Green's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
England
Faversham, Kent
Posts: 13,038
Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!
The top of the helmet should be 2 inches below the roll cage as far as I'm aware.
Stephen Green is offline  
__________________
The Priest Catcher
Honoured recipient of the BARC Browning Medal
Quote
Old 7 Oct 2002, 12:32 (Ref:397479)   #6
Grahambangers
Rookie
 
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location:
Stockton-on-Tees, North east england
Posts: 13
Grahambangers should be qualifying in the top 10 on the grid
Hi all,

I have spoken a couple of time to the scrutineers at croft and from my understanding there is two problems..
1)drivers and cars not actually looked at as one..drivers out of car wondering around etc....
2)there is no actual reg for this...most scrutineers recommend there is couple of inches but its not enforceable.
Grahambangers is offline  
Quote
Old 7 Oct 2002, 12:33 (Ref:397480)   #7
Dave Brand
Veteran
 
Dave Brand's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2001
England
Hadfield, Derbyshire (UK)
Posts: 6,358
Dave Brand is going for a new lap record!Dave Brand is going for a new lap record!Dave Brand is going for a new lap record!Dave Brand is going for a new lap record!Dave Brand is going for a new lap record!Dave Brand is going for a new lap record!
Quote:
Originally posted by EvilPumpkin
What's actually in the regulations regarding this?
Q 1.5.4 (a):

'An effective rollbar must be fitted with its top edge not less than 5cm above the helmet of the normally-seated driver.'
Dave Brand is offline  
Quote
Old 7 Oct 2002, 12:37 (Ref:397485)   #8
ss_collins
Veteran
 
ss_collins's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2002
Nigeria
Mooresville, NC
Posts: 6,704
ss_collins should be qualifying in the top 3 on the gridss_collins should be qualifying in the top 3 on the gridss_collins should be qualifying in the top 3 on the gridss_collins should be qualifying in the top 3 on the grid
Are you aware that not all cars require cages?
ss_collins is offline  
__________________
Chase the horizon
Quote
Old 7 Oct 2002, 12:48 (Ref:397500)   #9
PipSqueak111
Racer
 
PipSqueak111's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2002
England
Deepest, darkest Devon
Posts: 267
PipSqueak111 should be qualifying in the top 10 on the grid
FIA technical regs say that when taking a line from the top of the rear roll structure to the front roll structure, the helmet should be 70mm below the line between the 2 highest points. I should imagine this is a fair translation across to cages on the likes of Caterhams as well as single seaters.

Phill
PipSqueak111 is offline  
__________________
Time is an illusion, lunchtime doubly so!
Quote
Old 7 Oct 2002, 12:50 (Ref:397503)   #10
scrutineer
Racer
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location:
Manchester
Posts: 254
scrutineer should be qualifying in the top 10 on the grid
Having read this forum for a long time and not participated in any of it I thought after reading this I should register and reply to this as it is a bit of an attack on the scrutineering practice. I can assure you that every safety aspect of the car is carefully looked at and roll over structure is one of those key safety features. Of coarse there are specifications of the distance from the top of the drivers helmet to the top of the cage however as you point out we do not usually see the driver sat in the car (and if we did he hasnt got a helmet on as he hands it to us so we can check it conforms) but if we did they usually go away and put a cushion or a piece of foam in which might put them above (how can we prevent this). The responsibility must also fall onto the competitor to ensure they are bellow (after all it is their head that is going to hit the floor).
But it is a problem that is taken seriously and if it is reported and we are informed and it is deemed to be unsafe he/she will be black flagged and brought in. As you say we don’t want to see a marshal scraping up brains from the tarmac (very well put) but we are the ones that have to stand up in court and defend our selves.
EP yes there are regulations for this (around 5 pages) they can be found in the competitors yearbook ‘bluebook’ under section Q subsection 1 however it is in metric nowadays and is 5cm above the drivers helmet.
If you have any questions please send me a msg or leave a note on here and ill try and answer most of them. Or when you are next at a race meeting come over and have a look round we don’t bite(and there will be a blue book floating around if you realy want a look) although I thought they would send you a copy with you MSA card. But more importantly if you think something is unsafe tell either a scrutineer or a clerk and it will get looked at.
scrutineer is offline  
Quote
Old 7 Oct 2002, 12:51 (Ref:397504)   #11
Stephen Green
Race Official
Veteran
 
Stephen Green's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
England
Faversham, Kent
Posts: 13,038
Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!
Yes, we are aware that certain historic cars do not require roll cages. However, there is no excuse for a modern day car not to afford the driver the maximum protection in the case of an accident. The problem as I see it is that if you are unfortunate enough to turn the car upside down, no matter how tightly you are strapped in, you will drop a little in the seat. Now take a line from the top of the roll bar to the front of the car and see if your head will be buried either in gravel or tarmac. In a great deal of cases it will be above that line and you could be dead.

If drivers want to kill themselves in this manner that's their business. The trouble is that the doctors and marshals have to clear up the bits that are left.

You may have gathered I feel pretty strongly about this!

I'm not having a go at any of those who have answered the thread, merely at the complete lack of sense that prevails over such an important safety issue.
Stephen Green is offline  
__________________
The Priest Catcher
Honoured recipient of the BARC Browning Medal
Quote
Old 7 Oct 2002, 12:52 (Ref:397506)   #12
paul.hickman
Racer
 
Join Date: Jul 2002
United States
uk, mallorca & florida...
Posts: 133
paul.hickman should be qualifying in the top 10 on the grid
Stephen - 'vein' attempts and 'It came to a head on...' - all very medical. intended or Freudian...?
paul.hickman is offline  
__________________
“Every year there is a winner. Not every year there is a Champion” - Ayrton Senna, 1993
Quote
Old 7 Oct 2002, 12:53 (Ref:397508)   #13
scrutineer
Racer
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location:
Manchester
Posts: 254
scrutineer should be qualifying in the top 10 on the grid
ss collins as you point out not all cars require a roll over structure these are certain classes (historics etc)
scrutineer is offline  
Quote
Old 7 Oct 2002, 12:57 (Ref:397509)   #14
Stephen Green
Race Official
Veteran
 
Stephen Green's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
England
Faversham, Kent
Posts: 13,038
Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!
Scrutineer, welcome to ten-tenths and many thanks for your very informed reply. As I mentioned earlier, I actually wrote two Observers reports but have to say that nothing was done to my knowledge.

Marshals do appreciate the work you do especially as we all share the same love and enthusiasm for the sport. What worries me a great deal is that there is going to be a nasty accident at some stage where the drivers head has been injured from not conforming to the regulations. Then as we all know, overkill (excuse the pun) happens and the world take the rule book and go mad rewriting it.

My post was made as an attempt to bring this to light and hopefully get things moving in the right direction.

Are you able to offer advice on how we can achieve this as I know we both have the drivers safety first and foremost?
Stephen Green is offline  
__________________
The Priest Catcher
Honoured recipient of the BARC Browning Medal
Quote
Old 7 Oct 2002, 12:58 (Ref:397510)   #15
Stephen Green
Race Official
Veteran
 
Stephen Green's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
England
Faversham, Kent
Posts: 13,038
Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!
Sorry Paul, didn't intend to be humerous
Stephen Green is offline  
__________________
The Priest Catcher
Honoured recipient of the BARC Browning Medal
Quote
Old 7 Oct 2002, 13:05 (Ref:397512)   #16
scrutineer
Racer
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location:
Manchester
Posts: 254
scrutineer should be qualifying in the top 10 on the grid
One way we can all help is if pit/paddock marshals spot what they feel is a problem point it out before they are let out onto the track as they will know we are there in the paddock before races but not usualy for practice (as in one day event we are still going over the other cars).
If the spot them going out and radio it to race control it is amazing how quick they will have it sorted out.
Dave you seem to have a copy of the book as you say its under Q1.5.4a but the title for this section is 'other considerations' which means the drivers wont alway read them
scrutineer is offline  
Quote
Old 7 Oct 2002, 13:11 (Ref:397518)   #17
Stephen Green
Race Official
Veteran
 
Stephen Green's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
England
Faversham, Kent
Posts: 13,038
Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!
Many thanks for that advice, I will mention it to the paddock marshals at the next meeting. It would be helpful if the MSA were to issue guidance or advice to the organising clubs at the beginning of the season, or to point out that it may be an area worth looking into in greater depth?
Stephen Green is offline  
__________________
The Priest Catcher
Honoured recipient of the BARC Browning Medal
Quote
Old 7 Oct 2002, 17:33 (Ref:397698)   #18
Novice
Racer
 
Novice's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2002
England
Rochester, Kent
Posts: 383
Novice should be qualifying in the top 10 on the grid
Stephen at Brands the best place to catch the drivers whose crash helmet extends above or level with the roll cage would be the assembly area. Most of the drivers drive up to assembly without their crash helmets on so paddock would not be able to intercept them. For practice sessions assembly check scutineering tickets and noise tests so why not crash helmet / roll cage?
Novice is offline  
__________________
I'm not their Father, I'm just the taxi service!!!!!!
Its not worth mugging me, my kids beat you to it!
Now a Grandad
Quote
Old 7 Oct 2002, 18:33 (Ref:397753)   #19
Tony_J
Racer
 
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location:
North West England
Posts: 156
Tony_J should be qualifying in the top 10 on the grid
I remember a few years ago at Mallory Park a TR4A driver being told that his roll cage did not conform to specification in this respect. He spent several hours with hacksaw and arc welder extending the hoop above his head. He went on to race for a couple of seasons with this hoop extension.
Tony_J is offline  
__________________
Tony Johnston
Me a pseudo? Never!:)
Quote
Old 7 Oct 2002, 19:50 (Ref:397797)   #20
KayBee
Veteran
 
KayBee's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2002
England
Royston Vasey
Posts: 1,611
KayBee should be qualifying in the top 10 on the grid
Quote:
Originally posted by scrutineer
.If you have any questions please send me a msg or leave a note on here and ill try and answer most of them. Or when you are next at a race meeting come over and have a look round we don’t bite(and there will be a blue book floating around if you realy want a look) although I thought they would send you a copy with you MSA card.
For marshals they don't send a copy out with your MSA card - perhaps they should. However, I acquired one after the drawers were cleared out at one race meeting.

I would love to come over and watch what you are doing but you always appear to be very busy, first thing, and interruptions would not appear to be welcomed and then when you have a lull my duties call me trackside. However, I see from your location that you are based in Manchester will you be at Oulton on Saturday? I could drop by then if you are there. I would also like to know how do you become a Scrutineer? I have not seen the training/experience requirements listed anywhere.
KayBee is offline  
__________________
Green bit slippy, black bit grippy.
Quote
Old 7 Oct 2002, 20:03 (Ref:397808)   #21
Stephen Sutton
Rookie
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location:
Maldon Essex
Posts: 2
Stephen Sutton should be qualifying in the top 10 on the grid
The Caterham ‘hot rides’ were the worse offenders on Sunday at Brands. One passenger must have been three inches above the roll bar. I know the drivers are comfortable under racing speed but a tyre could still blow or suspension fail. Imagine the press if a passenger was killed on a hot ride!
Stephen Sutton is offline  
Quote
Old 7 Oct 2002, 21:16 (Ref:397884)   #22
Maisie
Veteran
 
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location:
UK
Posts: 1,631
Maisie should be qualifying in the top 10 on the grid
Looking at Rob Urquhart's TVR in the paddock on Saturday, I was struck by the fact that, while his seat is one of the ones which curl round to make a side head restraint system at the top, the roll cage was actually INSIDE the curve! I thought that the chassis or cage had twisted during his accident and put the cage inside the seat's confines, but a team member told me that it was normal. Surely that can't be safe!!
Maisie is offline  
Quote
Old 8 Oct 2002, 12:51 (Ref:398329)   #23
EvilPumpkin
CCNA
Royalridge Computing
A LARGE Teapot
Veteran
 
Join Date: Oct 2001
Ireland
Posts: 10,691
EvilPumpkin is going for a new world record!EvilPumpkin is going for a new world record!EvilPumpkin is going for a new world record!EvilPumpkin is going for a new world record!EvilPumpkin is going for a new world record!EvilPumpkin is going for a new world record!EvilPumpkin is going for a new world record!EvilPumpkin is going for a new world record!
Scrutineer, I wouldn't agree that this is an attack on scrutineering practice. I think it's a valid point and questions are being asked. That's hardly an attack. Also, fascinating though your blue book may be, it's not readily available in Ireland and it's also not valid here. Neither are the MSA regs you refer to.

As for inserts in the seats, I agree that the onus has to be on the driver to a certain extent. However, I'm totally with Novice on this one - all cars have to pass through assembly anyway. Let's face it, if a driver attempted to go out on the track with no helmet on at all, he'd be intercepted immediately. The same could quite possibly be applied to people who are obviously at the same height, or even above, their roll cages.

Would any of our Rescue collegues care to speculate on what kind of damage someone could expect to suffer if they take a heavy roll and their helmet is the same height as, or higher, than their roll cage? I would imagine the least you could expect is a concussion and possibly whiplash. The scope for head and neck injuries seems to be very wide.
EvilPumpkin is offline  
__________________
If you feel that the circuit is not safe for racing, please go into the pits and retire.
Quote
Old 8 Oct 2002, 13:18 (Ref:398348)   #24
scrutineer
Racer
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location:
Manchester
Posts: 254
scrutineer should be qualifying in the top 10 on the grid
EP that is what I said? I know paddock marshals and pit marshals are busy but like I said before it is imposible for us to get to the paddock during testing (most of the time) so if marshals had a quick look as the cars were waiting and stopped and going out that they think is to tall then this would help a lot.
I know the 'blue book' is not valid over there but there will be a rule which will be very much the same.
As for what would happen lets hope we never find out
scrutineer is offline  
Quote
Old 8 Oct 2002, 14:07 (Ref:398379)   #25
Stephen Green
Race Official
Veteran
 
Stephen Green's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
England
Faversham, Kent
Posts: 13,038
Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!Stephen Green has a real shot at the podium!
At least we all agree that it's not safe to let drivers out in that condition. As long as we know who it is who can stop them getting on the track is what really matters. If we all work together as a team, then with any luck we can avoid an horrific accident in the future!
Stephen Green is offline  
__________________
The Priest Catcher
Honoured recipient of the BARC Browning Medal
Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Roll couple or roll centre??? HELP!!!!!! jonners Racing Technology 66 30 Dec 2006 02:48
roll cages . . . .bolts VS welds zefarelly Racing Technology 9 29 Jan 2004 10:55
T45 vs CDS cages imull Racing Technology 3 25 Oct 2003 17:33
Alloy roll cages AlexF Racing Technology 12 24 Sep 2003 12:03
Roll cages zefarelly Racing Technology 2 19 Aug 2002 13:24


All times are GMT. The time now is 09:49.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Original Website Copyright © 1998-2003 Craig Antil. All Rights Reserved.
Ten-Tenths Motorsport Forums Copyright © 2004-2021 Royalridge Computing. All Rights Reserved.
Ten-Tenths Motorsport Forums Copyright © 2021-2022 Grant MacDonald. All Rights Reserved.