DC and Brundle commentary - Page 2

MarkG · 27 Mar 2011, 16:28 (Ref:2854272)

It was good commentary from the both of them, as expected, and is the general response from others here. A couple of detractors, but they probably say it's too hot when we have sunny days

Icebaby · 27 Mar 2011, 16:43 (Ref:2854280)

I thought Christian Horner did well now in his second year as a co-commentator for the BBC.......

**ghinzani** · 27 Mar 2011, 16:45 (Ref:2854284)

Watched half of the race and all of quali and I have to say its good to be in the hands of two experts who already seem comfortable together. Just a shame that wizened irish rug wearer is still there for his 'expert' analysis after the race.

Mr V · 27 Mar 2011, 16:57 (Ref:2854288)

Quote:

Originally Posted by VIVA GT

I thought that MB was a little overawed / unobservant at the beginning of the race, I'd spotted that Schumacher had a puncture and obviously that was why he was pitting, but then I was just watching it on my own, and not having to tell miilions of other people what was going on!

I noticed too that MB made a couple of mistakes, he named Trulli going off when it was Heikki for example, but is that now because its his job to talk first about what he see's whereas before, it was JA or JL's job and as an observer/expert he had a second or two to take it all in before mentioning something?

But all in all a good start. I was pleased that Martin didn't start shouting when the red lights went out but just reported what he (we all) saw.

Super Hans · 27 Mar 2011, 17:06 (Ref:2854296)

Quote:

Originally Posted by VIVA GT

I thought that MB was a little overawed / unobservant at the beginning of the race, I'd spotted that Schumacher had a puncture and obviously that was why he was pitting, but then I was just watching it on my own, and not having to tell miilions of other people what was going on!

You're absolutely right of course. But why did nobody ever cut Allen and Legard this sort of slack? We used to have a new thread every time either of those guys made that sort of error.

**Adam43** · 27 Mar 2011, 17:08 (Ref:2854299)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Super Hans

Bad commentators have the potential to ruin motorsport coverage, agreed. But I've never heard a bad F1 commentator. If you're a bad commentator, you don't get to do F1.

I disagree with this - bad commentators can happen on ITV.

Chiefy · 27 Mar 2011, 17:58 (Ref:2854344)

I liked it. A massive improvement over Jonathan "OOOF! THAT'S NOT WHAT HE WANTED THERE!" Legard. I thought Brundle and Coulthard were sufficiently energetic, for example when Vitaly Petrov passed the chequered flag for third. Maybe there is more to come in that regard, but as a first attempt - if you like - it was good and had everything it needed to have.

newlaprecord · 27 Mar 2011, 18:10 (Ref:2854350)

really smooth job, serious pro both of them. i think there are two things missing from it being perfect

1.) More enthusiasm

It was probably the MOST unispired way I have ever heard a commentator going on about a new season's star... when the red lights are off he should have SCREAMED the 2011 Forumula One season gets UNDERWAY!!! or something along those lines. Leggard was much better in raising his voice, even if it was artifical, we still need that I feel)

2.) A touch of humour

It is always good when the two commentators pull eachother leg every now and then. There is no chemistry between these two yet. Altho when Martin ask DC if it was 99% or 100% Rubens fault, that was funny, but we could do with some more.

Marbot · 27 Mar 2011, 18:19 (Ref:2854359)

I believe that Jonathan Legard was commentating for radio 5 live on the 'Oxbridge' boat race. Things happen much more slowly in that, so that even Legard can make reasonable assessments as to what might happen next.

Hard to know how he could make it sound as exciting as anything that ever happened to Jenson Button in a race ?

God job done by MB and DC, btw.

Super Hans · 27 Mar 2011, 18:29 (Ref:2854369)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Marbot

I believe that Jonathan Legard was commentating for radio 5 live on the 'Oxbridge' boat race. Things happen much more slowly in that, so that even Legard can make reasonable assessments as to what might happen next.

"Oxford are pushing on. Do Cambridge have a problem? Woof!...etc"

**touringlegend** · 27 Mar 2011, 18:42 (Ref:2854377)

DC fitted in to his role really well, Brundle did really good too. My only gripe would be I think Brundle is lacking the confidence to let what he wants to say actually be spoken. It's almost as if he feels that if he screams everyone will start to hate him.

Super Hans · 27 Mar 2011, 18:48 (Ref:2854381)

Quote:

Originally Posted by touringlegend

DC fitted in to his role really well, Brundle did really good too. My only gripe would be I think Brundle is lacking the confidence to let what he wants to say actually be spoken. It's almost as if he feels that if he screams everyone will start to hate him.

Brundle has always been a dry, cynical voice in the commentary box. If he was to start yelling and wooping it'd sound forced and people probably would hate him for it.

**touringlegend** · 27 Mar 2011, 18:55 (Ref:2854383)

Of course, I don't mean along the Legard proportions.. but especially at the start.. it just seemed to fall flat a bit.

delta · 27 Mar 2011, 19:03 (Ref:2854386)

Too be honest I did not give the comentary much thought.So i guess it was OK. One thing I do know I bet they would both rather be driving.

Marbot · 27 Mar 2011, 19:10 (Ref:2854390)

Quote:

Originally Posted by touringlegend

Of course, I don't mean along the Legard proportions.. but especially at the start.. it just seemed to fall flat a bit.

Maybe for the first and last couple of minutes of the race they could get James Allen to do the commentary ?

Super Hans · 27 Mar 2011, 19:12 (Ref:2854391)

Martin: "And as the cars line up on the grid, I hand you over to James Allen"
James: "Gooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!!"
Martin: "Thanks James"
DC: "Yeah, cheers mate."

**Aysedasi** · 27 Mar 2011, 19:39 (Ref:2854423)

I thought they were both excellent - seemed to gel very well together - they almost kept me awake during the last 4-5 laps......

**chunterer** · 27 Mar 2011, 19:59 (Ref:2854449)

Very natural and good chemistry as I expected. No bad news has come out of their partnership so far.

Brundle still managed to maintain his dryness with the odd quip or two and they seemed to share a few humourous moments too.

A more relaxed conversational style employed by the two of them rather than the typical pointed, formal, shouty style we have become used to in the past from various commentators.

Knowlesy · 27 Mar 2011, 20:48 (Ref:2854484)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Super Hans

Bad commentators have the potential to ruin motorsport coverage, agreed. But I've never heard a bad F1 commentator. If you're a bad commentator, you don't get to do F1.

Well now that clearly isn't true. There is a history of bad commentators for high profile events. ITV, especially, have a host of them. We have had James Allen, Jonathan Legard and Jonathan Palmer for F1 alone over the years.

What about the football? Names like Peter Drury ("Bye, bye big American sigh!!1!!1"), Clive Tyldesley, Jonathan Pearce, Guy Mowbray. And, once upon a time, Kenneth Wolstenholme. Dreadful, absolutely dreadful all of them. And all have done big games, be it European cup, international tournaments, FA Cup.

So, clearly, a lot of inept voices creep to the top somehow. It won't be long before Jacqui Oatley is doing the world cup final I expect.

**Born Racer** · 27 Mar 2011, 21:47 (Ref:2854516)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Marbot

I believe that Jonathan Legard was commentating for radio 5 live on the 'Oxbridge' boat race.

He was and some will be pleased to know that he did mention 'crucial'.

Edit: He said 'push on' just after 9:20 minutes in.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode...oat_Race_2011/

strider · 27 Mar 2011, 21:49 (Ref:2854519)

Quote:

Originally Posted by touringlegend

DC fitted in to his role really well, Brundle did really good too. My only gripe would be I think Brundle is lacking the confidence to let what he wants to say actually be spoken. It's almost as if he feels that if he screams everyone will start to hate him.

Yes, I think that's fair comment. Of the two, DC seemed to have less nerves, but I think Brundle will be fully into his stride by the time Malaysia comes around. A bit later in the day, thank goodness.

wnut · 27 Mar 2011, 23:48 (Ref:2854585)

Quote:

Originally Posted by newlaprecord

really smooth job, serious pro both of them. i think there are two things missing from it being perfect

1.) More enthusiasm

It was probably the MOST unispired way I have ever heard a commentator going on about a new season's star... when the red lights are off he should have SCREAMED the 2011 Forumula One season gets UNDERWAY!!! or something along those lines. Leggard was much better in raising his voice, even if it was artifical, we still need that I feel)

2.) A touch of humour

It is always good when the two commentators pull eachother leg every now and then. There is no chemistry between these two yet. Altho when Martin ask DC if it was 99% or 100% Rubens fault, that was funny, but we could do with some more.

Thoroughly enjoyed DC's comment:

Force India engineer on radio to Sutil: "You should think of trying to pass the car in front of you".

DC: "Like that idea wouldn't have occurred to him up to now!".

TWRv12 · 28 Mar 2011, 00:49 (Ref:2854612)

They are still missing things like Schu driving down the pitlane and into his box with a missing rear tyre/puncture. DC only mentions the puncture as MS departs box.

cmk · 28 Mar 2011, 03:10 (Ref:2854631)

Quote:

Originally Posted by TWRv12

They are still missing things like Schu driving down the pitlane and into his box with a missing rear tyre/puncture. DC only mentions the puncture as MS departs box.

Martin was already launching into his first opportunity to bring up the particularly slow pit lane speed limit and wasn't looking at the screen, I bet! DC was polite enough not to interrupt, but I think he'll get over that.

Some of DC's more humourous lines reminded me of things Brundle would say, so I think if they can both settle into their roles they'll do nicely; 2 very well-informed mates telling the rest of us about a race.

fourWheelDrift · 28 Mar 2011, 05:02 (Ref:2854637)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Born Racer

He was and some will be pleased to know that he did mention 'crucial'.

Edit: He said 'push on' just after 9:20 minutes in.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode...oat_Race_2011/

Brundle asked "what's he got left in the tank" in the closing stages of the Grand Prix so I fear he has been contaminated

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
How good was Brundle?	doug911	Formula One	53	4 Nov 2008 12:23
Poor commentary by Brundle	Raven	Formula One	26	17 May 2007 17:27
no Brundle Walk about	darcym	Formula One	17	4 Apr 2004 20:54
Brundle is biased!!!	neutral	Formula One	9	8 Jul 2000 05:12