|
||||||||||
|
||||||||||
|
2 Jun 2004, 23:38 (Ref:992106) | #1 | ||
Rookie
Join Date: May 2004
Posts: 33
|
Sound and Porsche's air-cooled engines
Has there been an analysis into the distinctive sound emmited by the old air-cooled engines in Porsche road cars? I know it is a complex mixture of sounds (fan, belts, exhaust, etc), but is there any one single component that dictates the very unique sound of these engines? I remember reading about 2-stroke kart engines, and there was some mention of the cooling fins being resonated as a reason for their (very loud) engine tones. Was this a factor with the Porsche engines?
|
||
__________________
"Trying is the first step towards failure" |
3 Jun 2004, 03:59 (Ref:992204) | #2 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Dec 2002
Posts: 706
|
I think you are right, some part of the sound must be due to the fins (a metallic ringing noise), overlaid by boxer thrum and fan roar.
Certainly the 996 has a less distinctive sound and has lost some of the high frequency noise (still sounds hot though). |
||
__________________
"If a man could be crossed with a cat, it would improve the man but deteriorate the cat." Mark Twain |
4 Jun 2004, 11:13 (Ref:993732) | #3 | ||
Racer
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 299
|
Not sure if this answers your question (or just tells you something that you already know) but...
The water jacket on a water-cooled engine does attenuate (quieten) the sound considerably. Not only does it quieten the motor overall, but it affects different frequencies to a greater or lesser degree. So in the first instance, that's one of the key factors for a unique "air-cooled" sound Installation (think of the engine bay as an echo chamber) and the relative noise of the exhaust and other ancilliaries also affect perceptions (I think of the 500cc F3s, where the exhaust noise is so loud it drows most of the air-cooled sound). I've not heard of resonating fins, but it sounds reasonable. |
||
|
5 Jun 2004, 08:06 (Ref:994489) | #4 | ||
Rookie
Join Date: May 2004
Posts: 33
|
Water jacket! Of course, I didn't even think about that. The attenuation (or lack thereof) of certain frequencies would be enough play change the characteristics of the sounds emitted.
|
||
__________________
"Trying is the first step towards failure" |
8 Aug 2005, 23:00 (Ref:1375384) | #5 | ||
Rookie
Join Date: Jul 2005
Posts: 20
|
theres nothing like a delicious engine sound.
anyone know for sure about the resonating cooling fins ? probably need very high frequency to get a metal plate of such little width to vibrate. |
||
|
10 Aug 2005, 16:24 (Ref:1379136) | #6 | ||
Racer
Join Date: May 2005
Posts: 262
|
How do you find the frequncey of a engine vibrating?
I wouldnt think its just from the RPM, nor RPM times number of cylinders. There is all the parts in the head too, to think about. Any ideas. |
||
__________________
"I wonder what the fastest anybodys been in the Eurotunel train?" |
11 Aug 2005, 03:50 (Ref:1379546) | #7 | |||
Veteran
Join Date: May 2004
Posts: 2,540
|
Quote:
racing59 - I think the "boxer" sound is more due to firing order and cylinder pairing. In a similar way a flat-plane crank V8 (eg Lotus Esprit or many racing engines) don't sound the same as "normal" V8's |
|||
|
10 Aug 2005, 20:58 (Ref:1379373) | #8 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2003
Posts: 3,523
|
The other thing you have to consider is that it is a boxer engine, and they have their own characteristic sound. Think of the difference, and more over the resonance of a V6 vs a straight 6. The V always sounds raspy, where the straight sounds silky, The Ferrari Boxer engines, vs their V12's. The boxers always had an edge, or probably more up to date - the sound of a scoobydoo impreza/legacy vs an inline 4.
But yes, the sound of a Porsche, flat 6, air cooled, is still, nice.... not as nice as a big V8 though.. |
||
__________________
There is no substitute for cubic inches. Harry Belamonte - 403ci Vauxhall Belmont!! A 700hp wayward shopping trolley on steroids!! |
11 Aug 2005, 03:58 (Ref:1379549) | #9 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Jul 2004
Posts: 511
|
I think the sound comes from the engine configuration as stated previously...
Compare the Flat 4 of the 356's and that of a WRX... Similar sound, but the WRX's is dulled (probably by the water jacket) On a side note, The "air" cooling in a misnomer...They are "oil" cooled, and the oil is cooled by the air. As the water is cooled by the air in "water" cooled engines. DKGandBH |
||
__________________
Look at my web page... |
11 Aug 2005, 21:55 (Ref:1380235) | #10 | |||
Rookie
Join Date: Jul 2005
Posts: 20
|
Quote:
maybe with a jacket oil sirculation pump ? in that case an air cooled engine would be even quieter than a water cooled one as oil is a "softer" fluid and has a higher tendency to dampen vibrations. sound waves even moves at a lower velocity in oil. |
|||
|
11 Aug 2005, 11:40 (Ref:1379756) | #11 | ||
Racer
Join Date: Apr 2003
Posts: 181
|
several things I believe make them nice sounding. One is the firing order and also that fact a flat 6 fires in opposition ie balanced. Also, Powers of 3 (Eg 6, 12) create harmonics that sound nice to the human ear.
Ever heard a 3 cylinder diahatsu with a broken exhaust? sounds not bad either! |
||
|
11 Aug 2005, 22:25 (Ref:1380254) | #12 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Aug 2004
Posts: 14,699
|
Yes I don't understand that statement either, I only had one flat 6 Porche engine apart and that was a 916 in the 70's and that was definitely air cooled in the same way as a flat 4 VeeDub engine.
|
||
__________________
You can't polish a turd but you sure can sprinkle it with glitter! |
11 Aug 2005, 22:33 (Ref:1380261) | #13 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Jul 2004
Posts: 511
|
That comes from the local Volkswagen specialist I worked for when I was on vacation from University...
Yes there is an aspect of direct air cooling (that is what the fins are for in the heads obviously), but the Oil also draws heat, and then is cooled by the air, and I was taking that to the extreme. DKGandBH |
||
__________________
Look at my web page... |
11 Aug 2005, 22:36 (Ref:1380262) | #14 | ||
Rookie
Join Date: Jul 2005
Posts: 43
|
Engine noise
On a Porsche 911 air cooled engine cooling is a combination of air being blown over the cylinders and head fins by the engine driven fan, and by the circulating engine oil removing heat from the engine and returning it via the oil cooler to the tank (dry sump) the oil acting as a medium to transfer the heat away from the engine components. One of the reasons I believe that Porsche went to water cooling was to quieten the motor sound to comply with noise control legislation in some countries, ie Switzerland
|
||
|
11 Aug 2005, 22:58 (Ref:1380273) | #15 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Aug 2004
Posts: 14,699
|
Yes but surely the same is true of a water cooled engine as the oil and associated coolers do their part to aid cooling as well.
|
||
__________________
You can't polish a turd but you sure can sprinkle it with glitter! |
12 Aug 2005, 00:43 (Ref:1380322) | #16 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: May 2004
Posts: 2,540
|
I agree Al, I dare say the bulk of heat load would be shed by the fins on the barrels and heads, there is not that much oil flow (particularly on cylinder walls) to extract much heat. However if air cooled engines overheat I believe it is the oil overheating before you ever get problems with the air cooling side of things being overloaded - which would be due to design and the engine driven fan.
Another reason for Porsche's change to water cooled engines from memory is was to comply with emissions regs, which I think might be due to the combustion temperature not being quite as high which reduces NOx emissions. |
||
|
12 Aug 2005, 12:29 (Ref:1380661) | #17 | ||
Racer
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 299
|
Vaguely related, I recently found a study of the pro's & con's of air cooling. interesting points were:
On a volume basis, you require 4,000 times the flow of air compared to water (I appreciate that eventually you will need to duct that air over a radiator if you use water cooling, but you can tailor flow through the radiator whereas it must be compromised over the engine). However, the air adds nothing to the weight of the car. You can expect a weight saving around 10lb (5kg) per litre of engine size. The finning around the barrels means a much longer engine (expect cylinder spacing not less than 1.4x bore size). A 3litre engine might need to be 8" longer. Not only does this add block weight, but vehicle layout may be compromised, and most crucially an 8" longer crankshaft is likely to be more fragile and susceptible to torsional vibration resonance. Care must be taken with finning around the head to avoid heat distortion (with the inlet side likely to run naturally cooler than the exhaust side). The air-cooled engine is less likely to be compromised by light damage (a stone hitting the fins is rather less of an issue that hitting an radiator), and fewer (or entirely removed) risks relating to the fan, fan belt, coolant leaks, dodgy thermostats, etc. In short, once you've got the design right, it will be almost bombproof. At the same power output, air cooling is unable to remove heat in detail areas as efficiently. So the combustion chamber surfaces run hotter (bad for combustion, more risk of pre-igintion limiting performance), as do valve seats, rings and top-end pin (increasing the risk of failure) and piston face (higher risk of burning a piston) |
||
|
12 Aug 2005, 18:12 (Ref:1380852) | #18 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Aug 2004
Posts: 14,699
|
With air cooled you get a lousy smelly heater as well especially if you have any oil leaks:-)
|
||
__________________
You can't polish a turd but you sure can sprinkle it with glitter! |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Porsche's in rallycross | Barrie | Rallying & Rallycross | 91 | 21 Jan 2017 09:24 |
Sound of V8 | pole2pole | Formula One | 17 | 24 Nov 2005 10:07 |
What Do They Sound Like? | PaulSands | A1GP | 12 | 30 Sep 2005 17:40 |
"Cooled" pits. | kuchi | Racing Technology | 9 | 14 Sep 2000 16:39 |